Inspector Sean McDermott – Manager, Domestic & Family Violence Team, NSW Police Force

Sean McDermott-2

The Americans tend to refer to domestic violence as domestic or spousal ‘abuse’. I think that this term encapsulates so much of what violence against women is about. It is much more than physical abuse. It is also the abuse of a relationship, of love, of trust, of financial inequality, of a family structure, and the fear of shame by the victim that can lead to feelings of helplessness and isolation. My aim is to expose such perpetrators for what they are and to give support and protection to victims so that they can live freely and be themselves.

When Sean McDermott arrived at the Domestic and Family Violence Team in September 2012, he brought with him the ‘baggage’ from his work as a general duties officer, a domestic violence liaison officer and a prosecutor – the lessons learnt and the injustices witnessed. ‘I had one clear overarching goal in mind: to make the experience of a domestic violence victim, in her journey from the first contact with police until her matter had been resolved in court, to be as simple and as well supported as possible. To do this would involve advocacy for changes to the law and also to procedures adopted by operational police.’

Sean joined the NSW Police Force (NSWPF) in 1996. From the beginning he was confronted by the magnitude and complexity of domestic violence (DV) – NSWPF responds to over 300 DV incidents a day during the course of a year. Like most other police officers, he clearly remembers his first arrest which was for a very serious DV assault on a young woman, committed in a public place by her ex-partner. While this was the first of many serious DV incidents that Sean would encounter, several aspects of this particular case have continued to resonate with him:

  • The sense of impunity that the perpetrator must have felt to commit this serious assault in a public place.
  • The lack of reaction by members of the public to the violence against the woman.
  • The limitations of the (then) police procedures in terms of supporting women following the immediate intervention by police.
  • The inadequacies of the criminal justice system in dealing with the domestic violence offence.

What also became increasingly clear to Sean as he gained more experience, was that the dynamic of violence against women generally boiled down to one issue: the sense of inadequacy felt by a surprisingly large proportion of men that resulted in their perceived need for control over women and children. That part was simple. The reasons why some women continued to endure repeated behaviour without taking action were much more complex and yet very understandable. These issues have to a large degree guided Sean in his career up to and including his current role.

With this in mind, Sean has worked with his team and the NSWPF’s Corporate Spokesperson, Assistant Commissioner Mark Murdoch, to overhaul the way NSWPF treats all domestic violence incidents, with probably more progress made in the past two years than in the previous 25 years. Sean says, ‘We have seen tremendous changes in the way police respond to violence against women both in terms of the quality of investigations and prosecutions but more importantly in the way they approach such incidents.’

Some of the major changes have included:

  1. The advocacy for and negotiation of legislation that will now allow for the automatic admissibility of video statements taken at the scene of DV incidents. NSWPF had pushed for this since 2008 but had not been successful. In January 2014, Sean formed and chaired a working group that had this specific goal. On 18 November 2014, NSW Parliament passed the bill that will allow for this to happen. The legislation is an Australian first (and in its construction probably also a world first) and will remove the need for victims having to give evidence from memory. This will alleviate the pressure they experience in court and will generally ease the journey of women through the court system.
  2. Advocacy for the negotiation and implementation of the Police Issued Apprehended Domestic Violence Order (ADVO) legislation, allowing police to accelerate the process of preventing perpetrators from continuing to threaten their victims.
  3. The introduction of the identification of risk factors as part of policing practice. Any people assessed at being at serious threat of harm will be referred to safety action meetings where agencies will work together to reduce the risk to victims.
  4. The establishment of DV clinics, the first of their kind in NSW and Australia, developed in consultation with the Women’s Domestic Violence Court Advocacy Service. In these clinics, Sean explains the realities of the court process to victims of DV, advises them of the limitations of the system and the tactics that can be used by legal representatives. The existence of these clinics has led to an increase in women willing to attend court and the preparations undertaken have ensured that they were more confident and offered better-quality evidence. This in turn led to an increase in convictions against perpetrators, meaning greater protection for women.
  5. The production of a DVD, demonstrating the work of the DV clinics, enabling more female victims throughout NSW to benefit from the facilities on offer. This has been translated into four languages (Arabic, Mandarin, Korean & Vietnamese).

Sean and his team are committed to ongoing work on the protection of women and children by improving police responses to domestic violence, ensuring that every offence warrants the investigation of all possible avenues of inquiry. They are determined to ensure consistency in the responses across the state ‘from Bondi to Bourke’ and beyond.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: